Meister Eckhart — The Infinite Can Help With the Shopping
Imagine spending thirty years trying to become spiritually enlightened.
You've read all the books. Attended the retreats. Bought the meditation cushion. Learned to speak about energy, presence and the deeper self with an expression of tremendous significance.
Then somebody knocks on the door.
They need help carrying their shopping.
You explain that you're currently occupied with the infinite.
They leave.
You return to contemplating universal love.
Somewhere, a medieval Dominican friar is probably rolling his eyes.
Meister Eckhart understood something that remains wonderfully inconvenient for people who enjoy the idea of spiritual enlightenment more than the business of living.
If the divine is somehow present at the deepest level of existence, why would recognising that presence require us to abandon the ordinary world?
And if we have discovered something so profound about unity, why does it sometimes make us less interested in the person standing beside us?
Eckhart's answer was not simply to tell people to be nicer.
He asked them to reconsider what they thought God, selfhood, detachment and spiritual awakening actually meant.
He did it with such extraordinary boldness that church authorities eventually condemned propositions extracted from his work.
And seven centuries later, people are still arguing about what he meant.
Which suggests he was asking some fairly interesting questions.
A master, not a medieval wellness influencer
Meister Eckhart was born around 1260 in Thuringia, in what is now Germany.
He joined the Dominican Order, studied theology, became prior of the monastery at Erfurt, and held demanding positions administering Dominican communities.
He taught at the University of Paris, one of medieval Europe's great centres of intellectual life.
In fact, the title Meister means master in the academic sense.
He wasn't a self-appointed spiritual guru who had discovered the secret to existence over a particularly impressive breakfast.
He was a highly trained theologian and philosopher.
His teaching involved Aristotle, Augustine, Neoplatonic philosophy, Christian scripture and the sophisticated intellectual arguments of medieval scholasticism.
He wrote in Latin and preached in German.
That combination mattered.
Latin allowed him to participate in the university's technical debates.
German sermons brought difficult theological ideas into the lives of people who didn't spend their afternoons reading university treatises.
His later work also involved communities of women religious, including Dominican convents in the Rhineland and Alsace.
There is a historical temptation to imagine everyone in the Middle Ages waiting passively for somebody important to tell them what God thought.
The reality was considerably more intellectually lively.
People were asking difficult questions about prayer, authority, poverty, the soul and the nature of God.
Eckhart wasn't above those conversations.
He was right in the middle of them.
The God beyond our picture of God
One of Eckhart's most challenging ideas concerns the distinction between our descriptions of God and the ultimate divine reality.
We have an impressive ability to imagine God as a much larger version of ourselves.
A supernatural person.
A cosmic ruler.
An extremely powerful manager who supervises the universe from outside it.
The office is presumably magnificent, although the complaints department appears difficult to contact.
Eckhart drew on the tradition of negative theology, which insists that the divine cannot be adequately captured by the ordinary concepts we apply to things within the world.
He spoke of the Godhead, emphasising a divine simplicity beyond the familiar distinctions through which we imagine a particular being.
This language is difficult, partly because it belongs to a Christian Trinitarian theology rather than a straightforward modern philosophy of impersonal consciousness.
Eckhart was not merely saying that God doesn't exist or that religious language is worthless.
He was suggesting that the deepest reality of God cannot be reduced to the images and categories we use to think about God.
That is quite an intellectual manoeuvre.
You begin with a word everyone thinks they understand.
Then you spend a lifetime explaining why the word cannot contain what it refers to.
It's enough to make a dictionary feel personally inadequate.
But the insight can be useful even for someone who doesn't share Eckhart's theology.
We frequently mistake our descriptions of reality for reality itself.
The map becomes the territory.
The diagnosis becomes the person.
The spiritual symbol becomes the thing it was supposed to help us contemplate.
Sometimes the first step toward understanding is recognising that the model is incomplete.
The prayer that upset the furniture
In a famous sermon about spiritual poverty, Eckhart expressed the startling wish that God might free him from God.
The wording sounds like an argument that has accidentally wandered into the wrong church.
But the point was not a simple rejection of religion.
He was challenging the images, expectations and attachments that people place between themselves and the divine.
If I seek God only as the being who will provide my preferred rewards, approve my plans and guarantee my personal success, perhaps I am mostly seeking a glorified version of my own desires.
I haven't escaped my little private world.
I've installed the universe inside it and appointed myself chief executive.
Eckhart's paradox tries to interrupt that arrangement.
What if the deepest spiritual discovery requires letting go of the very concept of God to which the ego has become attached?
The word ego is a modern shorthand here, not Eckhart's technical vocabulary.
But the practical problem is recognisable.
People can become attached to the identity of being spiritual.
They may be desperate to appear peaceful.
They may measure their progress against others.
They may even become rather competitive about how little they care about competition.
Human beings are magnificently capable of turning absolutely anything into a performance.
Including the refusal to perform.
Eckhart's challenge is that genuine freedom might involve becoming less occupied with the image we're trying to maintain.
The ground beneath the performance
Eckhart used the language of the ground of the soul.
He wasn't referring to a physical location somewhere behind the heart.
Nor was he describing a little glowing marble that could be discovered during surgery.
The image points toward a dimension of human spiritual and intellectual life that, in his theology, is profoundly related to the divine.
At this ground, he described a union with God that exceeds the ordinary distinction between a subject thinking and an object being thought about.
He also used images of a spark, a little castle, a temple and an openness capable of receiving the divine Word.
These metaphors are easily misunderstood when extracted from his arguments.
Eckhart was not offering a medical theory of the brain.
He was not proving that neurons collectively produce access to a universal cosmic database.
He was exploring a Christian account of the soul's deepest relation to God.
And yet the comparison with The Smiling Monad is revealing.
Eckhart's challenge is more immediate than another theory of the cosmos: can we stop making ourselves the centre of every encounter?
Eckhart's account of the ground of the soul suggests a radical intimacy between the deepest self and divine reality.
But he did not simply teach that all creatures share one empirically demonstrated consciousness.
His language of the Word, the Godhead and the divine life belongs to a distinct theological system.
The resemblance is worth exploring.
The difference is worth preserving.
Otherwise we've taken a remarkable medieval thinker, dressed him in modern spiritual vocabulary and informed him that he agreed with us all along.
A rather presumptuous way to conduct a conversation.
The strange idea of God being born now
Eckhart frequently spoke about the birth of the Word in the soul.
That may sound like a complicated theological explanation of Christmas.
In his preaching, however, the significance is not confined to something that happened long ago.
The divine Word is eternally communicated; the soul becomes receptive to what is always being offered.
This makes spiritual realisation something concerned with the present, not merely a memory of an ancient event.
The important distinction is not that a person creates God through private mental effort.
Eckhart's argument moves in almost the opposite direction.
The soul is to release its attachments so that it can become receptive to a divine activity that does not depend on the ego's management.
Think of someone desperately trying to hear a piece of quiet music while talking continuously.
They turn up the volume.
They buy more expensive headphones.
They write an elaborate review of the music they have not yet properly heard.
At some point, the useful intervention might be to stop talking.
The analogy doesn't prove any theology.
But it does suggest how attention can change when we cease filling every available moment with our own intentions.
There is a useful psychological observation here.
We sometimes become so busy trying to manufacture a particular experience that our efforts interfere with the experience itself.
And that brings us to one of Eckhart's most important ideas.
Detachment doesn't mean not caring
Eckhart spoke of detachment and releasement, associated with the German terms Abgeschiedenheit and Gelassenheit.
These can sound like instructions to stop caring about everything.
Sell your possessions.
Abandon your relationships.
Become emotionally unavailable.
Sit quietly in a room while other people deal with the consequences.
Congratulations, you've achieved the spiritual status of an exceptionally unhelpful housemate.
But that is not an adequate account of what Eckhart was trying to describe.
His concern was with the attachments that cause us to cling to things as possessions of the self.
Reputation.
Control.
Reward.
The need to make circumstances obey our wishes.
The demand that other people confirm our importance.
A person can care deeply about a friend without needing to control the friend's life.
They can work conscientiously without making the job title their entire identity.
They can enjoy beautiful things without believing their worth depends on owning them.
Detachment, understood this way, is not indifference.
It's freedom from a particular kind of possessiveness.
That distinction matters enormously.
Because the people who suffer most from our attempts at control are often the people we claim to love.
The person who needs to be right
Consider a disagreement between two people.
One says something unexpected.
The other immediately begins constructing a response.
They aren't listening anymore.
They're preparing the defence.
The conversation becomes a competition to protect an existing interpretation.
Nobody can change position because changing position would feel like losing.
Now imagine approaching the same disagreement with a little less attachment to being the winner.
You might still disagree.
You might still have better evidence.
You might need to establish an important boundary.
But there's suddenly room to discover what the other person means.
Eckhart's language about detachment offers one possible way to understand that freedom.
Not as the elimination of individual judgement.
As the loosening of the demand that every encounter must reinforce the self-image we brought into it.
The Smiling Monad's Circles of Support have a wonderfully practical version of that principle.
Leave your ego at the door.
That doesn't mean leave your experience, expertise or personality behind.
It means that when the conversation concerns another person's life, protecting your status isn't supposed to be the main activity.
The person at the centre deserves something more useful than a room full of competing reputations.
Without a why
Eckhart also spoke about acting without a why.
It's one of those phrases that can become wonderfully mysterious when printed on a photograph of a waterfall.
But it deserves more than atmospheric typography.
He was challenging the tendency to treat spiritual life as a transaction.
I perform the correct action.
I receive the correct reward.
I become holy, important, enlightened or otherwise entitled to a superior seat in the cosmic theatre.
What if an action can have value without being performed for some further reward?
A musician may play for the pleasure and meaning of the music.
A friend may help because the friend needs help.
A child may create something simply because creating it is enjoyable.
We don't always need to convert participation into a calculation of personal advancement.
This does not mean actions should be thoughtless or without consequences.
If you are driving a car, a very clear understanding of why you should stop at a red light is strongly recommended.
Nor does it mean people should provide endless unpaid labour because their generosity is supposedly more spiritually pure when unrewarded.
Exploitation doesn't become love because someone gives it a religious explanation.
The useful idea is that not every meaningful activity needs an external prize to justify it.
Sometimes the value exists in the experience and the relationship themselves.
A spiritual master meets the washing up
Now we arrive at the part of Eckhart's work that may be most important to The Smiling Monad.
In the Gospel of Luke, Jesus visits two sisters, Mary and Martha.
Mary sits listening.
Martha is occupied with the practical tasks of hospitality.
Traditional readings have often treated the sisters as symbols of contemplation and action, with Mary's attention to spiritual teaching regarded as the higher example.
Eckhart took an unusually provocative approach in his German Sermon 86.
He placed remarkable value on Martha.
She had learned to act in the world without losing her deeper grounding.
She could attend to practical responsibilities without becoming spiritually distracted by the ordinary work.
In Eckhart's reading, Mary's contemplative attention is valuable, but Martha represents a mature integration of inner understanding and outward activity.
Think about that.
One person is sitting in contemplation.
The other is preparing food, welcoming guests and dealing with everything required to make the gathering work.
And the medieval mystic suggests that the person doing the practical work may be displaying the more developed spiritual life.
Somewhere, people who have spent years using enlightenment as an excuse to avoid household chores are experiencing a slight disturbance in the force.
The point isn't that action is always superior to contemplation.
It's that the two need not be enemies.
The understanding reached in quiet reflection can be realised through the way we live.
There is no spiritual shortcut around another person
This is where the comparison becomes substantial.
The Smiling Monad's philosophy begins with the possibility of one infinitely interconnected consciousness, expressing itself through countless individual experiences.
Recognising a source is important within that story.
But the story does not end when someone has an interesting inner experience.
It continues through relationships.
The person who wants to communicate something.
The neighbour who's lonely.
The child discovering a new interest.
The friend who has had an awful day.
The person experiencing injustice.
We can spend hours discussing whether all beings share a deeper reality.
Meanwhile, someone might need a hand getting their shopping out of the car.
Helping them doesn't solve the philosophical question.
It does something else.
It changes the experience of two people participating in the same world.
Eckhart's Martha reminds us that contemplation shouldn't become an elaborate escape route from responsibility.
And The Smiling Monad adds an important emphasis.
Other people's individual experiences are not merely opportunities for our spiritual development.
They are their own experiences, deserving attention on their own terms.
We do not help someone simply to prove that we're good people.
We help because their life matters.
When the mystic becomes a problem for the institution
Eckhart's teaching eventually attracted formal scrutiny.
In Cologne, proceedings began against propositions associated with his writings and sermons.
He defended himself and appealed to the papal court at Avignon.
The controversy involved complicated questions about how divine unity, the soul and the birth of the Word should be understood.
Some of his most daring formulations could sound, when isolated, as though human beings were becoming literally identical with God in a way that eliminated distinctions fundamental to established Christian theology.
Eckhart argued that his teaching had been misunderstood.
He maintained that he intended to remain within the faith of the Church, and he expressed willingness to retract genuine doctrinal errors.
But the process continued.
He died, probably in early 1328, before the final papal decision.
On 27 March 1329, Pope John XXII issued In agro dominico, condemning twenty-eight propositions associated with Eckhart's work: seventeen treated as heretical and eleven criticised as suspect or dangerously expressed.
The exact nuances of those classifications matter to historians.
So does another detail.
The bull condemned propositions; it did not formally declare Eckhart himself a heretic.
He was dead by then.
This is not a simple story of one pure hero defeated by a completely ignorant institution.
It is a complicated episode involving theology, authority, interpretation, institutional interests and the power to determine which ideas could be publicly taught.
But it does raise an uncomfortable question.
What happens when an institution becomes so concerned with guarding its approved descriptions of truth that it struggles to consider what a difficult thinker actually means?
And what happens when a thinker communicates so provocatively that their intended distinctions become almost impossible for others to recognise?
Both questions deserve attention.
Not every condemned thinker is a misunderstood genius
There is a modern temptation to celebrate anyone criticised by an institution as automatically correct.
Apparently, if an authority disagrees with you, the disagreement is proof that you've discovered something extraordinary.
Unfortunately, reality is more complicated.
Institutions can protect power and suppress important enquiry.
They can also identify genuine errors.
A controversial proposition can be daring and insightful.
It can also be confused, poorly supported or wrong.
Eckhart's case requires careful historical understanding, not a modern motivational slogan about how great minds are always persecuted.
He was an extraordinary scholar and preacher.
His thought was sometimes startling.
And some of his formulations created real theological difficulties within the tradition he belonged to.
The Smiling Monad should learn from that complexity.
It can ask radical questions about universal consciousness.
Others should be free to challenge those questions.
A philosophy doesn't become more credible by declaring criticism proof of its spiritual superiority.
It becomes more credible when it can explain itself clearly, distinguish evidence from speculation and remain willing to learn.
That isn't less adventurous.
It's simply less arrogant.
Is the soul already divine?
Here is another difficult question.
If the deepest ground of the soul is united with God, what exactly distinguishes the individual from the divine source?
Eckhart used powerful language about the identity or intimacy of the ground of the soul and the divine ground.
That language is part of why his work became so controversial.
Yet his theology also retains a complex account of creation, the Word and the relation between God and creatures.
It would be misleading to translate everything into the modern claim that each human being is literally the whole universe pretending to be an individual.
The Smiling Monad's origin story is different.
It proposes an original, unified consciousness whose contemplative activity gives rise to distinct thoughts, experiences and ongoing unfolding worlds.
Eckhart didn't write that account.
He was concerned with the eternal divine Word, the soul's receptivity and the theological structure of union with God.
They share a fascination with what the apparent individual might be at the deepest level.
But the explanation of that depth differs.
And the differences are not annoying details to remove during editing.
They are the reason the conversation has substance.
Eckhart, Plotinus and the long road toward unity
The similarities between Eckhart and Plotinus are substantial.
Both place great importance on what lies beyond ordinary conceptual distinctions.
Both describe a movement toward unity.
Both use language that challenges the idea of the self as an isolated thing with complete understanding of its source.
Eckhart's thought, however, is not simply Plotinus with Christian labels attached.
His framework involves the Trinity, the eternal Word, scriptural interpretation and a particular Christian account of spiritual transformation.
Plotinus's One lies beyond Intellect.
Eckhart's Godhead is often described in language that also challenges ordinary conceptual categories, but his theology cannot be detached from the Christian structure of his work without substantial distortion.
Spinoza, examined earlier in the series, proposed a single substance identified as God or Nature.
Eckhart did not present the same philosophical system.
Spinoza's account of nature, substance and attributes differs sharply from Eckhart's Christian understanding of the soul and divine Word.
The Smiling Monad begins with consciousness as the ultimate source and gives continuously unfolding individual experience a distinctive role.
We can recognise family resemblances without building an imaginary family in which everybody agrees about everything.
Some of the most interesting things happen precisely where they don't.
What about suffering?
Mystical language can become dangerous when used carelessly.
Tell someone that their deepest self is beyond suffering, and they may find comfort.
But tell a person experiencing abuse that their pain doesn't matter because the ultimate reality is one, and you've converted a philosophical proposition into cruelty.
The distinction is essential.
A change in perspective may help somebody endure circumstances they cannot presently change.
It does not justify those circumstances.
Nor should detachment be used to discourage grief, anger or requests for help.
A person who is distressed doesn't have to achieve mystical serenity before their needs become legitimate.
A disability doesn't reflect spiritual deficiency.
Illness doesn't indicate inadequate consciousness.
And somebody seeking fair treatment isn't demonstrating excessive attachment merely because they refuse to accept injustice.
The Smiling Monad's emphasis on peace has to be compatible with accountability.
Recognising a deeper unity should increase our attention to the consequences of how people are treated.
Not provide a sophisticated vocabulary for looking away.
Eckhart's Martha offers a useful corrective here, too.
Sometimes the most spiritually meaningful response isn't to discuss the higher nature of reality.
It's to do the work that needs doing.
The difficulty of hearing silence
There is also something fascinating about Eckhart's emphasis on inward stillness.
Human life is now saturated with opportunities to avoid silence.
We have phones, headphones, televisions, recommendations, reminders, alarms and a nearly unlimited supply of content explaining why our attention should be directed somewhere else immediately.
We can travel through an entire day without encountering a moment in which nothing has been selected for us to consume.
Some of those technologies are wonderful.
Music can offer connection.
A familiar recording can provide comfort.
Communication tools can open opportunities that didn't previously exist.
But constant activity can make it difficult to recognise what is happening within our own experience.
Eckhart's emphasis on release and receptivity provides one way to think about this.
Not everybody finds quietness comfortable.
Some people experience silence as anxiety.
Others find rhythm, movement or music more regulating than stillness.
There is no reason to insist that everyone practise contemplation in the same form.
The useful principle is not a compulsory silence programme.
It's freedom from being endlessly dragged away from the experiences that actually matter to us.
For one person, that might be meditation.
For another, a long walk.
For another, working in a garden.
For another, singing enthusiastically to music that everyone else in the car has heard forty-seven times.
The form is less important than whether the experience makes room for presence, confidence and connection.
Being yourself without becoming the centre of everything
There is a subtle balance to be found between self-love and self-centredness.
The Smiling Monad encourages people to live happily and confidently in their own rhythm.
That doesn't require a person to pretend they are unimportant.
It doesn't demand endless sacrifice.
And it certainly doesn't require dissolving their individuality into whatever everyone else finds convenient.
But the ego can become a problem when personal preference turns into a demand for universal obedience.
I like this activity, therefore everyone should enjoy it.
I understand the situation, therefore nobody else needs to speak.
I have discovered the truth, therefore disagreement is evidence of ignorance.
Eckhart's critique of attachment can help interrupt that tendency.
We can remain ourselves without needing every other person to confirm us.
We can have convictions without turning them into an identity that must be defended at all costs.
And we can recognise the limits of our viewpoint without abandoning what we've learned.
Sometimes the most revealing sign of confidence is the ability to say, 'I might have misunderstood.'
It's a modest sentence.
It can change an entire relationship.
The problem with spiritual celebrities
Eckhart's modern popularity also deserves a little scrutiny.
His words appear in collections alongside Buddhist teachers, Sufi poets, Hindu sages, contemporary psychologists and people whose actual relationship with philosophy is mostly selling expensive candles.
Sometimes the comparisons are illuminating.
Sometimes the historical traditions have been stripped away, leaving vague statements about being one with everything.
An ancient writer becomes an inspirational product.
A difficult sermon becomes a sentence on a photograph.
And the distinction between Christian theology, Buddhist non-self and a modern theory of universal consciousness vanishes beneath an attractive sunset.
This isn't intellectual openness.
It's an impressive form of philosophical recycling.
Eckhart's thought is difficult.
He makes claims that are theological, not merely psychological.
He belongs to a particular historical tradition.
And parts of his argument are genuinely challenging to reconcile with other accounts of reality.
That's fine.
We don't have to make everyone identical before we can enjoy a conversation.
The Smiling Monad becomes more interesting when these differences remain visible.
It should invite readers to examine the ideas, not simply collect prestigious names that seem to endorse them.
The deepest revelation might be practical
Return to the person who knocked on the door.
The shopping still needs carrying.
The person is still standing outside.
And our supposedly enlightened philosopher is still deciding whether helping would interfere with the important business of transcending the self.
Eckhart's treatment of Martha gives us a wonderfully simple answer.
No.
Practical care doesn't need to be an obstacle to spiritual understanding.
It may be one of the ways understanding becomes real in everyday life.
But let's not make the point too sentimental.
Helping someone doesn't automatically make the helper compassionate in every other part of their life.
A single good deed isn't a certificate of permanent enlightenment.
And caring for another person requires more than deciding, from a position of superior wisdom, what they ought to want.
They need opportunities to express their own preferences.
They need genuine choices.
They need respect for the experience they are actually having.
Love and care become meaningful within relationships, not merely within the helper's self-image.
The Smiling Monad's account of shared consciousness has to preserve that individuality.
Otherwise an inspiring story about unity becomes another excuse for deciding everybody else's life on their behalf.
The master who challenged the expert
Eckhart died around 1328.
His name survived the condemnation of propositions from his writings, the changing interests of religious communities and the immense transformations of European intellectual history.
Today, he is read by theologians, philosophers and people interested in meditation, spirituality and nondual accounts of reality.
His writings have also been repeatedly quoted outside their original context.
That creates a challenge.
We can admire his daring without pretending his metaphysics has been scientifically verified.
We can appreciate his language of unity without erasing the Christian theology that gives it shape.
We can explore detachment without turning it into indifference.
And we can learn from his critique of self-importance without demanding that everyone become less individual.
The most valuable part of Eckhart's legacy for The Smiling Monad may not be any claim about the precise structure of the divine ground.
It may be his refusal to separate spiritual understanding from the way a person acts.
The source is not an excuse to abandon the world.
Recognition is not a prize that places somebody above their neighbours.
And peace is not demonstrated by remaining serenely indifferent while someone else struggles.
The ultimate nature of existence may be a magnificent mystery.
The everyday world is not merely a distraction from it.
It's where our experiences are happening.
It's where relationships grow and change.
It's where we discover that somebody else's perspective is not the same as ours.
And it's where the consequences of our choices are felt.
Eckhart's theology and The Smiling Monad's philosophy do not offer the same explanation of reality.
But they ask a question worth placing beside one another.
If we've found a deeper understanding of who we are, does it make us more present to the lives around us?
If not, perhaps we've mistaken the performance for the discovery.
The person at the door is still waiting.
Put down the book.
Give them a hand.
You can discuss the infinite on the way back.
Ben Grey · 14 November 2026
Further reading
- Meister Eckhart, German Sermon 86 — the Mary and Martha interpretation.
• Meister Eckhart, German Sermon 52 — spiritual poverty and freedom from attachment.
• Meister Eckhart, The Talks of Instruction (often titled Counsels on Discernment).
• Meister Eckhart, The Book of Divine Consolation.
• Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, "Meister Eckhart" (2023): https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/meister-eckhart/
• Yoshihiko Abe, "The Image of Mary in Eckhart's German Sermon 86" (2011): https://doi.org/10.20716/rsjars.85.3_645
• "Doing and Seeing in Meister Eckhart and Michel Henry," Dionysius 29 (2011): https://ojs.library.dal.ca/dionysius/article/download/dio29bullerwell/2524
• Meister Eckhart, The Complete Mystical Works, translated by Maurice O'C Walshe, edited by Bernard McGinn.
• Bernard McGinn, The Mystical Thought of Meister Eckhart: The Man from Whom God Hid Nothing (2001).
• Pope John XXII, In agro dominico (1329), historical analysis and text discussed in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
