All essays

Essay · 13 November 2026

Criticise the System, Not the People

The NDIS, Australian taxpayers and the extraordinary economics of human suffering

There's a growing frustration in Australia about the cost of the National Disability Insurance Scheme.

And fair enough.

Australians contribute billions of dollars to a system intended to improve the lives of people with disability. They have every right to ask whether that money is being spent effectively.

But somewhere in the argument about government expenditure, fraud, bureaucracy and the rising cost of disability support, we've started confusing the people who need assistance with the system responsible for delivering it.

That's a pretty significant mistake.

People with disability aren't the problem. The way we've designed the system around them deserves far more scrutiny.

Follow the money

In 2024–25, NDIS payments totalled approximately $46.3 billion.

That's an enormous public investment. And it deserves serious accountability.

But before deciding that the answer is simply to reduce funding, perhaps we should examine what we're actually paying for.

Much of the NDIS operates through fee-for-service arrangements. Providers receive payment for delivering support, often calculated by the hour.

The problem is that the financial reward is linked to the quantity of services delivered, not necessarily the quality of the outcomes achieved.

A provider delivering more support hours may receive more revenue, regardless of whether those additional hours improve someone's life.

Meanwhile, a provider that successfully helps someone develop greater independence, build relationships and reduce unnecessary assistance may receive less revenue.

We have somehow created a system where reducing the problems a person experiences can also reduce the financial opportunities available to those delivering the services.

And then we act surprised when the cost keeps rising.

The independent NDIS Review identified precisely this problem. It wasn't some wild conspiracy theory. It was an acknowledged weakness in the way the scheme pays providers.

When things go wrong, the paperwork starts

Consider someone with complex disability support needs.

They may experience significant communication difficulties, anxiety, sensory challenges or distress in unfamiliar environments.

Poorly matched support can contribute to incidents, restrictive practices and escalating difficulties.

Every incident potentially generates more paperwork, professional assessments, behaviour support reviews, administrative processes and arguments about funding.

Sometimes additional funding is entirely justified. People experiencing greater risks or increased disability-related needs should receive appropriate assistance.

But there is an uncomfortable financial contradiction.

A system that recognises and funds escalating problems without equally recognising successful prevention risks making human suffering more financially visible than human wellbeing.

Now consider an alternative.

A skilled worker develops an understanding of someone's individual communication. They recognise signs of discomfort before distress escalates. They create opportunities for choice, connection and confidence.

The person begins enjoying activities that previously caused anxiety.

Their life improves.

Incidents decline.

What financial recognition does that improvement receive?

And what happens if the reduction in incidents is subsequently interpreted as evidence that the person no longer needs the very support responsible for the improvement?

It's a bizarre possibility: the better the support works, the easier it may become to justify taking it away.

The registration illusion

Australians are entitled to expect exceptionally high standards from organisations receiving public money to support vulnerable people.

Registration, audits, compliance procedures and government oversight are supposed to provide accountability.

They have important roles. But they don't automatically demonstrate that excellent support is being delivered.

In September 2025, the Australian National Audit Office found that the NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission was only partly effective in its regulatory functions.

That raises serious questions about how well the system identifies poor performance, protects participants and responds to risks.

A registered provider may have extensive policies, procedures and administrative structures.

But can the person receiving support make meaningful choices?

Are their communication needs understood?

Are unnecessary restrictions being reduced?

Are they safely participating in their community?

Are they happier?

These are the questions that should sit alongside compliance requirements.

And being unregistered doesn't automatically make a smaller provider inferior either. Quality should be established through competence, safeguarding, accountability and the experiences of participants, rather than organisational size or registration status alone.

Stop treating people as expenses

There's another problem with the public conversation about the NDIS.

People with disability are increasingly discussed in terms of what they cost.

Not what they contribute. Not the relationships they develop. Not the lives they lead.

Just numbers on a government spreadsheet.

Yet the NDIS was never intended merely to keep people alive and out of trouble.

It was designed to support participation, independence, opportunity and choice.

For some individuals, independence means employment, education or living with less assistance.

For others, particularly people with profound lifelong disabilities, independence means having the necessary assistance to exercise genuine control over their lives.

Choosing what to eat. Where to go. Who to spend time with. How to communicate. What makes them happy.

A person who requires extensive support can still enjoy an independent life in the sense that matters most: a life directed by their own preferences, rather than someone else's convenience.

And that support should not be treated as a failure simply because it remains necessary.

What taxpayers should be asking

There are important questions for anyone concerned about the NDIS budget.

Why are providers financially rewarded primarily for delivering hours rather than demonstrating quality?

Why are successful preventative supports not more consistently recognised?

How much public money is consumed by duplicated administration and unnecessary services?

How do we distinguish genuine ongoing support needs from avoidable dependency created by poor service delivery?

Why aren't outcomes such as communication, choice, community participation and wellbeing given greater prominence when evaluating services?

And how can we improve financial accountability without creating incentives for providers to avoid people with complex disabilities or manufacture superficial measures of success?

Those are difficult questions.

But they're considerably more useful than blaming people with disability for needing assistance.

Better outcomes are better value

Reform should focus on aligning financial incentives with the purpose of the NDIS.

Pay providers fairly for skilled and necessary support.

Establish stronger standards for quality and safeguarding.

Recognise successful preventative work, not just responses to crises.

Measure meaningful outcomes identified by participants themselves.

Protect ongoing funding when improvements depend on ongoing support.

Reduce unnecessary bureaucracy and strengthen independent oversight of provider performance.

And ensure that any outcomes-based funding arrangements cannot be manipulated by rejecting participants with complex needs or withdrawing necessary assistance.

This isn't an argument that better outcomes will always cost less.

Some excellent services will remain expensive because supporting people with complex needs requires significant resources.

But Australians should be able to see that public money is supporting meaningful lives rather than merely financing an expanding industry around disability.

The Smiling Monad perspective

The NDIS debate needs to separate legitimate scrutiny of public spending from suspicion aimed at people whose lives depend on support.

From that perspective, the way a society supports people with disability tells us something important about how it understands human value.

People are not financial liabilities whose worth must be justified by productivity.

Nor should their difficulties become commercial opportunities disconnected from their wellbeing.

There is nothing wrong with businesses making a reasonable profit by delivering excellent support.

But the economic rewards should encourage excellent support, not simply the continuation of billable need.

The goal is not to force people to become less dependent on assistance. It is to help them exercise greater freedom, choice and control over their own lives.

And if that requires substantial lifelong support, then providing it well is part of the achievement.

Direct your frustration where it belongs

To anyone looking at the enormous NDIS budget and wondering whether Australia is getting value for money, that is a reasonable question.

Ask it.

Demand accountability.

Examine the financial arrangements, bureaucratic structures, service quality and incentives.

But don't confuse the system's shortcomings with the people it was created to support.

Cutting necessary assistance can reduce expenditure on a spreadsheet while transferring costs and suffering to people with disability, their families, hospitals and communities.

It doesn't necessarily make Australia more efficient.

And it certainly doesn't establish that we've created a better society.

The question isn't simply how much we can cut from the NDIS. It's how much better the NDIS could work if its financial incentives genuinely reflected its purpose.

Australians deserve responsible expenditure.

People with disability deserve dignity, opportunity and meaningful control over their lives.

We shouldn't have to choose between those outcomes.

Because a system that actually works for the people it's supposed to support is precisely what taxpayers should be paying for.


Ben Grey · 13 November 2026 The Smiling Monad — Explorations into the Nature of Reality

Reference notes