Bruce Hornsby and the Range — The Way It Is, Until It Isn't
Bruce Hornsby, Tupac Shakur, a beautiful piano line, and the extraordinary human habit of calling injustice inevitable.
There is something almost suspicious about the opening of Bruce Hornsby and the Range's 1986 song The Way It Is.
The piano is beautiful. The rhythm is relaxed. The melody wanders along with the quiet confidence of someone who has nowhere urgent to be. You could listen to it on a drive through the countryside and feel rather pleased with the world.
Then you listen to the words.
Oh.
Apparently, we have a few things to discuss.
A Beautiful Song About an Ugly Reality
Hornsby grew up in Williamsburg, Virginia, in a society still struggling with the legacy of racial segregation. In interviews, he has described writing the song from his experience of local narrow-mindedness and intolerance. The lyrics move between poverty, contempt for people who cannot find work, racial exclusion and the comfortable assumption that certain arrangements will never change.
He wrote the song in 1985 and released it with the Range in 1986. It became a major hit. A song about discrimination, with extended improvised piano passages, reached the top of the American singles chart. So much for the music industry's presumed ability to recognise what the public will enjoy.
The song also looks back to the Civil Rights Act of 1964, a landmark law prohibiting important forms of discrimination, including employment discrimination. Laws matter: they establish enforceable rights, change institutional obligations and give people means to challenge unfair treatment. But legislation cannot, by itself, remake every prejudice in somebody's mind.
Hornsby captures that gap beautifully. A society can announce that it has changed while some of its people continue behaving as though nothing should.
The Most Dangerous Sentence in the Room
There is a familiar defence of every unreasonable arrangement: That's just the way it is.
The school has always done things this way. The organisation has its policies. The worker is only following instructions. The person doesn't fit the program. The rules weren't written for someone like them.
Each explanation might contain a genuine practical constraint. Sometimes rules protect people and limit arbitrary power. But the existence of a rule does not establish its fairness, and the age of a custom does not prove its wisdom.
Hornsby's reply is wonderfully short: “But don't you believe them.”
Five words. No three-hour committee meeting required.
They expose the difference between describing a present arrangement and declaring it permanent. Gravity is not particularly interested in our objections. Human institutions, however, are human creations. They can be investigated, debated, repaired and, when necessary, replaced.
The people who benefit from them may not be thrilled. Progress has an unfortunate habit of inconveniencing somebody's comfortable routine.
Why We Defend What We Know
Psychology offers one way to understand why unfair systems can feel so natural. John Jost and Mahzarin Banaji's work on system justification describes processes through which people rationalise existing social arrangements, sometimes even when those arrangements work against their interests.
The familiar world offers predictability and a story about why things are as they are. Questioning it can mean acknowledging that practices we once defended were unfair, or that our own advantages were not entirely deserved. That is not a pleasant discovery, especially if we've spent twenty years explaining the opposite to everyone else.
System justification is a research framework, not a diagnosis to attach to every person who disagrees with us. There are many reasons people defend institutions, including legitimate concerns about safety, stability and unintended consequences. The useful question is whether a defence is based on evidence and human outcomes—or simply the comfort of leaving things alone.
Hornsby's song enters through the ears before we have finished preparing our arguments. Its beauty gives an uncomfortable subject room to be heard.
We Are Not Watching the Unfolding
The Smiling Monad offers a distinctive philosophical response. Its account of an infinitely unfolding, interconnected consciousness is a metaphysical perspective rather than a scientific finding. The ethical question that follows is straightforward: if we understand ourselves as participants in an interconnected reality, what do our choices contribute to it?
We are not spectators of the unfolding. We are part of what happens next.
That means recognising injustice without challenging it is not a position outside the story. Our actions matter, and so can our inaction. A harmful arrangement may continue because nobody believes they can change it, because somebody benefits from it, or because those with the power to intervene decide it is easier not to.
Responsibility does not mean omnipotence. None of us can personally correct every wrong. Nor should people suffering injustice be made responsible for rescuing themselves while those with influence remain comfortably uninvolved. Responsibility grows with knowledge, opportunity and power.
The philosophy's interconnectedness is not an instruction to smile serenely while someone else is being treated badly. That would be a rather alarming interpretation of happiness.
It asks something more demanding: to value our own lives while recognising that other people's experiences are not disposable. Peace within ourselves should make us more capable of thoughtful action, not less willing to take it.
The way it is describes the present. It does not excuse the present or decide the future.
When Tupac Took Up the Melody
One of the song's most extraordinary later lives came through Tupac Shakur. His Changes, issued in 1998 after his death, sampled Hornsby's unmistakable piano foundation and took the conversation into another musical world.
Hornsby was a white American songwriter reflecting on racism and inequality he had witnessed, including attitudes in the Virginia community where he grew up. Tupac spoke from a Black American perspective shaped by experiences and public arguments about race, poverty, violence and policing. These perspectives are connected, but they are not interchangeable. Nor should one be treated as merely illustrating the other.
The transformation matters. The same melodic idea travelled between genres and communities, meeting listeners who might never have encountered the original. It gained another voice, another rhythm and another confrontation with the persistence of injustice.
This is an unexpectedly elegant illustration of creative unfolding. One artist's work becomes part of another's expression. Neither moment exhausts the possibilities of the music. Listeners carry it into their own lives, and the conversation continues.
And there is a sharp little irony here: a song about the belief that nothing changes has kept changing.
Why the Piano Matters
Imagine the subject delivered as an angry lecture. Some people would listen; others would immediately rehearse their objections. Hornsby instead gives us a flowing piano part, jazz-influenced harmony and room for improvisation. The arrangement is melodic, reflective and unusually spacious for a pop hit.
The music is not simply happy. There is melancholy in its warmth. The steady motion of the piano sits beside lyrics describing a society stuck in repetitive excuses.
That tension is part of its power. The song doesn't need to shout to be confrontational. It allows the listener to feel the contradiction between the beauty of shared human creativity and the ugliness of exclusion.
Music cannot replace evidence, legal protection, collective organising or material reform. But it can open a conversation before everybody has decided which side of an argument they occupy.
Sometimes the melody gets through the front door while prejudice is still busy checking the guest list.
The Problem Isn't Only American
It would be convenient to leave this as a history lesson about the United States. Australia has its own histories of exclusion, including the dispossession and discrimination faced by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, and continuing questions about unequal treatment and institutional power.
The same habits appear in smaller settings. A student struggles with a standard teaching method, and we decide the student is the problem. A person communicates differently, and a support service concludes that the person is difficult to support. A rule exists, so the discussion ends.
Sometimes an individual needs additional support. Sometimes the environment needs to change. Often both things are true. What matters is that we examine the person, the setting, the expectations and the evidence before declaring the arrangement inevitable.
An inclusive school or disability service isn't inclusive because its brochure says so. The test is what people actually experience: whether they are understood, whether their choices matter, whether they can participate, and whether the system responds when something isn't working.
That also means listening when the people most affected tell us what we have failed to notice.
Peace Is Not Permission to Look Away
There is a difference between acknowledging reality and consenting to injustice. We can recognise the circumstances of the present without treating them as morally acceptable. We can seek peace without demanding silence from people who need change.
Not every disagreement is evidence of oppression, and not every proposal for reform will succeed. Responsible action requires curiosity, evidence, proportion and a willingness to consider consequences. But uncertainty is not a good reason to abandon people whose dignity is at stake.
Sometimes the contribution is a public campaign. Sometimes it's changing a workplace practice, challenging a discriminatory policy, making a classroom more accessible, or simply choosing to listen when another person says something isn't right.
These are not glamorous acts of cosmic heroism. They're ordinary human decisions. Which is rather encouraging, because most of us don't own a cape and have enough trouble finding the car keys.
The Piano Is Still Playing
Forty years after The Way It Is, the question remains: how much of what we call inevitable is simply maintained by habit, unequal power or a failure of imagination?
Progress is not automatic. Rights can be won and weakened. People can learn and forget. A song does not guarantee anything. But history gives us plenty of examples of people changing arrangements that once looked immovable.
That is why the refusal at the heart of Hornsby's song matters. The present is real. It is not final.
We are not required to approve of every condition under which life unfolds. If we are part of the unfolding, we share responsibility for how we participate in it—and those who possess the greatest ability to help have the least excuse for pretending they cannot.
The way it is does not have to be the way it stays.
Especially when somebody insists otherwise.
Ben Grey · The Smiling Monad · 14 November 2026
Research and further listening
- Harrington, R. (1987, February 3). “In Grammy Range.” The Washington Post. Contemporary interview with Hornsby.
- Hornsby, B., interviewed by Stereogum (2019). On The Way It Is and improvisation.
- United States National Archives. Civil Rights Act (1964).
- Jost, J. T., & Banaji, M. R. (1994). “The role of stereotyping in system-justification and the production of false consciousness.” British Journal of Social Psychology, 33(1), 1–27. DOI.
- Shakur, T. (1998). Changes. Release and sample credits.
Continue reading: Shōganai — When It Can't Be Helped, on acceptance, resilience and the danger of surrender. For a different exploration of the everyday expression, see It Is What It Is.
